Should I rent or buy?

3 min read

3 questions to ask yourself as you consider renting vs buying

Should I rent or buy? This is a question you may be asking yourself as your lease is coming up for renewal. Or, maybe, you’ve been perusing homes in your area for a while. Renting offers flexibility and a relatively maintenance-free lifestyle, among other things. And, buying has clear incentives as well, especially when it comes to building wealth over time. Ultimately, the decision is yours, hinging on your desired lifestyle, financial situation, and personal goals. Below, we highlight key considerations along with questions to ask as you explore each option.

What can I afford?

Whether you choose to rent or buy, making sure you can afford the home you're in is the first step and arguably the most important consideration to keep in mind. If you're renting, you'll likely pay a security deposit as well as one month's rent up front. As a common practice, you can review your salary (after tax) and apply the 50-20-30 rule. According to this rule, 50% of your income should go toward “needs,” including rent, utilities, and groceries; 20% should be placed directly into your savings; and the last 30% can go toward “wants.”

When it comes to owning a home, you can begin by calculating your debt-to-income ratio. Your debt-to-income ratio compares how much you owe at the end of the month to what you earn. An ideal debt-to-income ratio is 36% for many mortgage companies, but that does NOT count you out of homeownership. There are several mortgage programs to help you secure your home, affordably. Other factors to note include your down payment and any other short-term expenses you'll incur.

More on how to calculate housing affordability here.

A common misconception many people make is, “I won't be able to afford it.” In the second edition of Your First Home, Gary Keller and Jay Papasan tackle this myth head on.

“Until you do the math, you don't know what you can or can't afford,” they write. “If you are currently paying rent, generally you can afford to buy. From a financial point of view, in the United States, the tax savings on mortgage interest alone usually make up most of the difference between rent and a mortgage payment – the tax write-offs you get at the end of year will generally help you save a significant amount of money.” The real question is, “Can I really afford to keep renting?”

Similar to a mortgage, rent adds up, but has no long-term financial gain.

Rent10 Years20 Years30 Years

Build your equity, not your landlord’s

The chart above shows how much money over the course of 10, 20, and 30 years you may spend on rent. If you chose to own a home, these costs will go directly toward building your own home equity and net worth. According to Federal Reserve data from 2019, homeowners had a median financial net worth of $255,000, while renters net worth was just $6,300. Meaning, homeowners have nearly 40 times the net worth of renters. And the great news is that historically, home values have risen over time!

Read More: A Tale of Wealth Building and Affordability.

Until you do the math, you don't know what you can or can't afford


How much flexibility am I seeking?

The flexibility to get into a home quickly, as well as not being locked into a long-term mortgage, can be a very appealing factor of renting, especially if you know your personal or professional life will be in a constant state of transition or flux.

That said, keep in mind that life can shift quickly regardless of whether you have planned for it or not.

When it comes to homeownership – though it’s recommended you stay in your home 3–5 years to avoid capital gains tax and break even on your investment – you are not locked down. You have several options, including renting your home out (allowing you to keep your asset and build wealth over time), working with a trusted real estate agent to sell your home for the highest price, or partnering with a cash-offer program such as Keller Offers to get your home sold quickly, conveniently, and hassle-free.

How important is stability to me?

Aside from money and flexibility, stability is something to also weigh out in your decision to rent or own. With renting, while you may have more flexibility, your landlord ultimately sets the cost of your rent and has the ability to change it. When you own a home and take part in a fixed-rate mortgage program, your monthly payment will remain the same.

From a community perspective, how important to you is building long-term relationships? Due to the short-term nature of renting, tenets tend to be more transient. If you own a home and live in an area with other homeowners, you are more likely to meet others who are staying longer and have an increased ability to build long-term relationships.

Additionally, when you purchase a home, you truly have the option to make it your own, customizing to your heart’s content.

Want to explore more?

If this article piqued your interest, there’s much more in store for you! Contact a Keller Mortgage loan officer today to explore the topics noted here!

Keep learning


First-Time Homebuyer’s Guide (Part One)

First-time homebuyer fears can range from “I can’t afford to buy a home” to “I can’t buy a home because my credit score is too bad.” While it can be natural to have these thoughts, it’s important to face fears with facts. Let's take affordability, for instance.


First-Time Homebuyer’s Guide (Part Two)

In part two, we will explore three more components of the first-time homebuying experience so you can embark on it with ease and confidence. Each magnificent tip below is brought to you courtesy of Your First Home (Second Edition), authored by Gary Keller and Jay Papasan.

Equal Housing Logo

NMLS #1025894

Consumer Access

Keller Home Loans is a division of Mutual of Omaha Mortgage, Inc., NMLS ID 1025894. 3131 Camino Del Rio N 1100, San Diego, CA 92108. AL Consumer Credit License 22123; AK Broker/Lender License AK1025894. AZ Mortgage Banker License 0926603; AR Combination Mortgage Banker/Broker/Servicer License 109250; Licensed by the Department of Financial Protection & Innovation under the CA Residential Mortgage Lending Act, License 4131356; CO Mortgage Registration 1025894; CT Mortgage Lender License ML-1025894; DE Lender License 028515; DC Mortgage Dual Authority License MLB1025894; FL Mortgage Lender Servicer License MLD1827; GA Mortgage Lender License/Registration 46648; HI Mortgage Loan Originator Company License HI-1025894; ID Mortgage Broker/Lender License MBL-2081025894; IL Residential Mortgage Licensee MB.6761115; IN-DFI Mortgage Lending License 43321; IA Mortgage Banker License 2019-0119; KS Mortgage Company License MC.0025612; KY Mortgage Company License MC707287; LA Residential Mortgage Lending License 1025894; ME Supervised Lender License 1025894; MD Mortgage Lender License 21678; MA Mortgage Broker and Lender License MC1025894; MI 1st Mortgage Broker/Lender/Servicer Registrant FR0022702; MN Residential Mortgage Originator Exemption MN-OX-1025894; MS Mortgage Lender 1025894; MO Mortgage Company License 21-2472; MT Mortgage Broker and Lender License 1025894; NE Mortgage Banker License 1025894; NV Exempt Company Registration 4830. Licensed by the NH Banking Department, Mortgage Banker License 19926-MB; Licensed by the NJ Banking and Insurance Department. NJ Residential Mortgage Lender License 1025894; NM Mortgage Loan Company License 1025894; NC Mortgage Lender License L-186305; ND Money Broker License MB103387; OH Residential Mortgage Lending Act Certificate of Registration RM.804535.000; OK Mortgage Lender License ML012498; OR Mortgage Lending License ML- 5208; PA Mortgage Lender License 72932; RI Lender License 20163229LL. RI Loan Broker License 20163230LB; SC BFI Mortgage Lender/Servicer License MLS-1025894; SD Mortgage Lender License ML.05253; TN Mortgage License 190182; TX Mortgage Banker Registration 1025894; UT Mortgage Entity License 8928021; VT Lender License 6891; VA Mortgage Broker and Lender License, NMLS ID #1025894 (; WA Consumer Loan Company License CL-1025894; WI Mortgage Banker License 1025894BA; WY Mortgage Lender/Broker License 3488. Toll Free #: (877) 978-1922. Subject to Credit Approval. For licensing information, go to: